We don't differentiate between sexes even when an individual might be significantly bigger and more athletic, outside of sports with weight classes. So what's your point?
Well, we're talking about sports. Are you implying that because swimming doesn't have weight classes that it somehow justifies whatever it is you're trying to say?
Why don't women who are similar in weight/height play in the NBA, MLB, MLS, etc? Why don't female fighters fight against men in the same weight class in MMA, boxing, kickboxing, etc? Surely it's not because they're at a disadvantage.
What is a "better" way? Claiming you "identify" as one or the other?
You mentioned "reality" earlier. So why is it that you are ignoring the reality of biology?
How does you ignoring the genetic influences and hormones that causes people to be transsexual any better? And why should sports be considered significant enough to bar someone from participating?
Again, what should people that have both do?
Repeating the same terrible argument doesn't make it better.
Well, we're talking about sports. Are you implying that because swimming doesn't have weight classes that it somehow justifies whatever it is you're trying to say?
Why don't women who are similar in weight/height play in the NBA, MLB, MLS, etc? Why don't female fighters fight against men in the same weight class in MMA, boxing, kickboxing, etc? Surely it's not because they're at a disadvantage.
How does you ignoring the genetic influences and hormones that causes people to be transsexual any better? And why should sports be considered significant enough to bar someone from participating?
Again, what should people that have both do?
Repeating the same terrible argument doesn't make it better.
Not being able to answer doesn't make it a terrible question. He said it's down to biology, so how does biology fix that issue?
There it is. Can’t answer questions with serious answers so we resort to making fun of people.
You’re a fantastic representation of why people can’t have a rational discussion.
Have the courage to reply to me at least.
You have an unserious position. Not even cis gender women can compete with other cis gender women on the professional level apparently. It's a fucking clown show where the rules are being made up as we go.
Not even "real women" like Castor Semenya, Christine Mboma, and Beatrice Masilingi are allowed to compete because of that sort of fear mongering.
No I'm okay with assaulting bigots. Big difference. We can have a respectable conversation on trade or whatever, and agree to disagree when opinions don't align.
On this topic however there's nothing to discuss. That's cut and dry.
Oh, its far from "cut and dry"
A biological woman, competing in a sport for biological women, doesn't think its fair to have to compete against a biological male. And that worthy of being assaulted in your opinion.
The only thing that is "cut and dry" is that your opinion that people should be assaulted if their opinion differs from yours is a very very dangerous position to take.
Do you think that's her only stance regarding trans people?
A biological woman, competing in a sport for biological women, doesn't think its fair to have to compete against a biological male. And that worthy of being assaulted in your opinion.
The only thing that is "cut and dry" is that your opinion that people should be assaulted if their opinion differs from yours is a very very dangerous position to take.
Do you think that's her only stance regarding trans people?
I don't know. But its the part relevant to the conversation I was having with Smitty
Do you think that's her only stance regarding trans people?
I don't know. But its the part relevant to the conversation I was having with Smitty
Great, so why can't people who were "born women" compete with them like the previously stated.
Evidently all that was required for some that passes for "biology" was have vagina and be called woman. But this pesky little thing called bimodal sex got in the way I suppose.
I don't know. But its the part relevant to the conversation I was having with Smitty
Great, so why can't people who were "born women" compete with them like the previously stated.
Evidently all that was required for some that passes for "biology" was have vagina and be called woman. But this pesky little thing called bimodal sex got in the way I suppose.
So, what is your solution? Abolish womens and mens divisions and just have everyone compete in a free for all?
Great, so why can't people who were "born women" compete with them like the previously stated.
Evidently all that was required for some that passes for "biology" was have vagina and be called woman. But this pesky little thing called bimodal sex got in the way I suppose.
So, what is your solution? Abolish womens and mens divisions and just have everyone compete in a free for all?
Ideally at least for competitive/pro sports decided by actual biology, testosterone, hormone levels etc. So yes that would mean men and women would be competeting in some circumstances.
But then again, it's just sports so it's a none serious argument to begin with and not a real issue for America to deal with, and the fact that legislation has to be considered in the first place is a an embarrassment for everyone involved.
So, what is your solution? Abolish womens and mens divisions and just have everyone compete in a free for all?
Ideally at least for competitive/pro sports decided by actual biology, testosterone, hormone levels etc. So yes that would mean men and women would be competeting in some circumstances.
But then again, it's just sports so it's a none serious argument to begin with and not a real issue for America to deal with, and the fact that legislation has to be considered in the first place is a an embarrassment for everyone involved.
Sports are "none serious"? You realize that sports in america is a multi multi billion dollar industry right?
Also, good thing there's a backlash now, right before the campaign turns two years old in 2 months. Once a woke ad campaign turns 2 years old, it mutates into a much more dangerous form.
It's a mistake to simply laugh at smitty's ignorance. He's sounding the bullhorn, pay serious attention. Led by the comically ironically self-named antifa, these fascists are all about using violence to impose their twisted world on the country. Mock their jack boot costumes at your peril, they're packing a Molotov cocktail and you are given the choice to submit or fight back.
And the (D)OJ and administration is on the fascist side.
A penis or vegina is a dogshit way to differentiate athletic ability. What of the people that have both?
It's a mistake to simply laugh at smitty's ignorance. He's sounding the bullhorn, pay serious attention. Just because he attended the University of of Playbox at Basement doesn't mean we should dismiss what is happening with our once real schools.
The "professor" is a PhD (no, I'm not calling him doctor) self bio- Senior Lecturer in the Department of Anthropology and Managing Faculty Director for the Center for Civil Rights and Racial Justice in the Law School at the University Pittsburgh. He is a socio-cultural anthropologist earning his Ph.D from the University of Texas at Austin in Anthropology focusing in Black Diaspora Studies and Masculinity. His research interests include the social constructions of race and racism, masculinity, gender, sex, Black Feminist and Black Queer theory, anthropology of sport and Black Diaspora. www.anthropology.pitt.edu/people/gabby-m-h-yearwood
Woke is making school ever more expensive and students stoopidder. That is what is behind the push for taxpayers to finance this nonsense. The country gets poorer both financially and intellectually.
Post by EPIC Sir Tinley on Apr 8, 2023 4:31:16 GMT -8
Back on topic, this is why all normal people should reject this nonsense at every level and every opportunity. Like all disease, looking the other allows it to spread and cause more carnage. When you see any person, group or company endorse, support and or promote this bullshit it is a mistake to shrug it off. You must do what you can to minimize it and improve the health of the country.